The best remodeling company for your home should have experience with your type of project, work in your town, and explain what your budget will cover. A bathroom renovation in Smithtown calls for a different shortlist than a second-story addition in Nassau County.
We compared customer reviews, homeowner discussions, project portfolios, business records, and published service information to identify these 10 companies worth considering.
Use the comparison below to find your project type. Then read the listings for the evidence behind each selection, budget information, and questions to ask before requesting an estimate.
Once you have a shortlist, use our guide to choosing a remodeling contractor on Long Island to check licenses, estimates, references, and how each company manages the work.
Which Long Island remodeling companies should you consider?
The numbers organize the guide. They do not rank workmanship from first to tenth. “Best for” describes our assessment of project fit among the companies researched.
| Company | Based in | Best for | Budget information found |
|---|---|---|---|
| Islandwide Contracting | Ronkonkoma | Full-service remodeling with design, selections, and project management | No published minimum found; free estimates |
| Kuhn Construction | Islip | A managed design-build renovation | Company-listed Houzz range: $50,000–$900,000 |
| OZ General Contracting | Bellmore | Kitchens with custom cabinetry | Company publishes kitchen tiers; see listing |
| DJ’s Home Improvements | Franklin Square | Design guidance and accessibility updates in Nassau | Company-listed Houzz range: $20,000–$500,000 |
| NDA Kitchens and Construction | Nesconset | Kitchen and first-floor renovations with detailed scheduling | Current project minimum requires confirmation |
| Magic Touch Contracting | Port Jefferson Station | Kitchen layout changes and adjoining rooms | No current minimum verified |
| Preferred Remodeling & Construction | Smithtown | Bathrooms and individual-room renovations | No current minimum verified |
| Long Island Creative Contracting | Miller Place | Whole-home renovations in Brookhaven and nearby towns | Cost guide available; current minimum unverified |
| Shells Only Complete Home Improvements | West Babylon | Dormers and second-story additions | Project-specific estimate required |
| Center Island Contracting | Farmingdale | Additions and renovations with budgets above $100,000 | Company-listed Houzz range: $100,000–$1 million |
Published ranges describe different scopes. They are not estimates for the same job, guaranteed prices, or confirmed minimums.
If your business made it on this list and you want your contact info displayed with yout listing, feel free to reach out.
How we selected these companies
We focused on firms based in Nassau or Suffolk County that offer residential remodeling. We gave more weight to reviews describing completed work, communication, cleanup, scheduling, repeat hiring, and problem resolution than to general praise.
Sources included Houzz, Angi, GuildQuality, BBB, public Reddit discussions, and customer reviews reproduced by Birdeye and Trustindex. Company websites helped establish services, locations, processes, and published prices. Contractor-written profile descriptions and portfolios remain company-supplied information, even when hosted on another website.
This is a research shortlist, not a certification of workmanship or licensing. We did not inspect projects, interview customers, or obtain insurance certificates. Current county license status was not independently verified: Nassau’s lookup blocked access, and Suffolk’s form did not provide business-level results through the research interface. Each listing identifies that limitation.
Ratings below are snapshots of the pages available during research. Some pages are cached. Google figures reproduced elsewhere are labeled as such; combined-platform ratings are not presented as Google ratings. Review samples can overlap, so we have not added them together.
Islandwide Contracting
Ronkonkoma
Best for: Homeowners who want a full-service remodel, with help on design, material selections, ordering, and project management.
Review snapshotHomeAdvisor 5.0/5, nine reviews, including some imported from Google; a separate Islandwide Painting & Contracting profile 4.5/5, nine reviews; BBB 4.2/5, five reviews. These are separate snapshots, not a combined score.
Budget informationNo published project range or minimum found. The company offers free estimates covering labor and materials. Request a written proposal showing selections, allowances, and exclusions.
Service area: Nassau and Suffolk, including Islip, Smithtown, Sayville, Patchogue, Holbrook, and surrounding communities.
Services: Kitchens, bathrooms, basements, dormers, extensions, design and planning, carpentry, flooring, painting, roofing, siding, windows, and doors.
Business history: BBB records a June 2019 start and identifies Andrew Snofsky as the owner. The company advertises more than 30 years of combined experience among its team.
License status: The company states that it is licensed and insured. Current county license status and insurance coverage were not independently verified.
Why we selected them
Islandwide suits homeowners who want guidance throughout a renovation. Its design services cover layouts and material selections, while customer reviews describe help understanding the project, coordination, and crews who respect the home. That supports considering them when managing the renovation yourself would be difficult.
What makes them different
Owner Andrew Snofsky manages each project, with design support to help you choose materials and finishes. You make the selections; the team handles ordering, pickup, and coordination. The arrangement brings the agreed work and materials into one project price, reducing the purchasing and scheduling you need to handle yourself.
What to know before contacting them
Ask what the project price includes and how upgrades or unexpected work affect it. Request references from similar renovations. Feedback includes complaints about workmanship and delays, which the company disputes. Discuss how concerns are documented, who handles corrections, and what the advertised one-year workmanship warranty covers.
Kuhn Construction
Islip
Best for: Homeowners who want design, planning, and construction managed together.
Review snapshotGuildQuality 4.9/5, 213 reviews; Houzz 4.8/5, 15 reviews.
Budget informationHouzz lists $50,000–$900,000; confirm scope and minimum.
Service area: Nassau and Suffolk, including Islip, Babylon, Huntington, and Brookhaven.
Services: Kitchens, bathrooms, additions, basements.
Business history: Since 1986; BBB lists 40 years.
License status: County verification pending.
Why we selected them
Kuhn has one of the more substantial customer-feedback records in this comparison. GuildQuality reports 314 responses from 486 surveys sent. Its published results include 98% satisfaction with construction quality and 97% with problem resolution. These are survey results, not an inspection of the work.
What makes them different
An August 2026 kitchen review describes an organized team from design through completion. Other customers describe help choosing materials and communication with a project manager. That supports considering Kuhn when you want assistance making decisions and coordinating the work.
What to know before contacting them
The published cost range covers several project types. Ask whether your project fits their current workload and budget requirements. Request a sample schedule and the name of the person responsible for updates, change orders, and the final list of unfinished items.
OZ General Contracting
Bellmore
Best for: A kitchen renovation where cabinetry and storage need to fit your space.
Review snapshotAngi 5.0/5, 140 reviews; Houzz 5.0/5, eight reviews.
Budget informationCompany’s 2026 kitchen guide lists $30,000–$65,000 for its midrange tier and $65,000–$120,000+ for a luxury gut renovation.
Service area: Nassau and Suffolk; confirm your address.
Services: Kitchens, bathrooms, cabinetry, interior renovations.
Business history: BBB records a 1985 start; the company advertises roots dating to 1976.
License status: County verification pending; published license identifiers differ between sources.
Why we selected them
OZ’s customer reviews provide specific evidence of custom cabinetry, design help, and repeat work. A July 2026 Angi reviewer describes cabinets made in-house. Other reviews describe kitchens followed by bathroom or basement projects. That makes OZ worth considering when fitted storage is central to your renovation.
What makes them different
The company says it manufactures cabinetry in Bellmore. Customer accounts also describe a designer helping with selections and a project manager checking progress. Ask to see cabinet construction samples and a completed kitchen with a layout like yours.
What to know before contacting them
BBB records an October 2026 bathroom complaint involving the threshold, fixture fit, and a refund. The customer subsequently confirmed resolution. Discuss clearances and floor transitions before approving plans. Treat the website’s price tiers as company guidance and request an itemized estimate for your home.
DJ’s Home Improvements
Franklin Square
Best for: Nassau homeowners who want design help, including changes that make a home easier to use.
Review snapshotHouzz 5.0/5, 36 reviews; Birdeye reproduces 4.9/5 from 14 Google reviews.
Budget informationHouzz lists $20,000–$500,000.
Service area: Nassau communities including Garden City, Floral Park, Mineola, and Oceanside.
Services: Kitchens, bathrooms, additions, interiors, accessibility design.
Business history: Company reports operating since 1990.
License status: County verification pending; profile lists H18C4240000.
Why we selected them
DJ’s reviews contain examples beyond a finished room looking good. One homeowner describes bathroom safety features that helped her remain in her home. Another describes the company handling permits, inspections, and subcontractors for a garage. Those accounts support its fit for homeowners who need help planning how a space will function.
What makes them different
Customers repeatedly identify Vita’s design assistance and Jerry’s construction oversight. The company also describes a client portal for schedules, selections, photographs, and finances. This may suit you if you want to review decisions before construction progresses.
What to know before contacting them
The Google review sample reproduced by Birdeye is small. Ask for recent references with your specific needs, especially for accessibility work. Confirm design fees, material allowances, and whether the proposal includes the work of any architect or engineer your project requires.
NDA Kitchens and Construction
Nesconset
Best for: A kitchen or first-floor renovation where you want a detailed work schedule.
Review snapshotHouzz 4.5/5, 16 reviews; Trustindex displays 4.9/5, 69 reviews.
Budget informationNo current minimum verified. Houzz’s cost field contains a formatting error.
Service area: Nassau and Suffolk; company lists projects from Manhasset to the East End.
Services: Kitchens, bathrooms, additions, whole-home renovations.
Business history: BBB records a 1990 start.
License status: County verification pending.
Why we selected them
NDA’s reviews repeatedly describe a useful practice: giving homeowners a schedule and telling them what will happen the following day. That detail appears in older Houzz reviews and in feedback dated 2026 on Trustindex. It is relevant if you plan to remain in your home during construction.
What makes them different
The evidence extends beyond cabinet replacement. A June 2026 reviewer describes a ranch renovation with relocated walls and structural supports. The project portfolio includes a Huntington whole-house remodel and kitchens in Manhasset and Port Washington.
What to know before contacting them
The review scores differ across platforms. Read both samples and ask for recent references. Request a scope that identifies design, demolition, structural work, painting, and finish materials separately. Confirm which tasks the company performs and which you must arrange yourself before comparing the estimate with another contractor’s.
Magic Touch Contracting
Port Jefferson Station
Best for: Changing a kitchen layout and renovating the rooms around it.
Review snapshotHouzz 4.8/5, 44 reviews.
Budget informationNo current minimum verified.
Service area: Central and northern Suffolk; profile also lists Nassau.
Services: Kitchens, bathrooms, additions, interiors.
Business history: Company profile reports a 1984 start.
License status: County verification pending; profile lists 9753-H and H18H0890000.
Why we selected them
Magic Touch’s Houzz reviews describe projects that connect several rooms. One customer reports opening the kitchen, den, living room, and dining room. Another describes a kitchen update that preserved more of the existing space. That suggests a useful company to consult when deciding how much renovation your home actually needs.
What makes them different
A four-star reviewer describes problems during a kitchen, bathroom, and flooring project, then credits the owners with resolving them. Specific accounts of handling problems carry more weight than a promise that every job runs perfectly.
What to know before contacting them
Ask for references from projects involving the same layout changes you are considering. Confirm who assesses structural changes and obtains approvals. No reliable project minimum emerged from the sources reviewed. A lower aggregate score appears on Porch, so review the underlying feedback before choosing.
Preferred Remodeling & Construction
Smithtown
Best for: A bathroom renovation or a defined list of improvements in Suffolk.
Review snapshotBirdeye reproduces 4.9/5 from 99 Google reviews; five reviews also appear on Houzz.
Budget informationNo current minimum verified.
Service area: Smithtown, Huntington, Islip, and surrounding Suffolk communities.
Services: Bathrooms, kitchens, interiors, windows, doors, trim.
Business history: BBB records a December 2001 start.
License status: County verification pending.
Why we selected them
Preferred has customer accounts that fit homeowners tackling individual rooms or work after a home purchase. A bathroom reviewer describes daily arrival times, updates about the next day’s work, and communication with the owner. Another describes window and door replacements alongside a list of inspection-related repairs.
What makes them different
The review evidence includes both bathroom renovations and smaller finish work. A Houzz customer also describes receiving help with materials and having minor issues corrected. That makes Preferred worth considering when your project is more contained than an addition or whole-house renovation.
What to know before contacting them
One customer reported receiving the lowest estimate among their bids. That does not establish Preferred as the cheapest company today. Ask what materials you purchase, what the contractor supplies, and how changes are priced. BBB’s complaint page displayed zero complaints when reviewed.
Long Island Creative Contracting
Miller Place
Best for: A whole-home renovation in Brookhaven or a nearby Suffolk community.
Review snapshotHouzz 4.9/5, 26 reviews.
Budget informationCost guide available; no current minimum verified.
Service area: Company describes coverage generally from Dix Hills to Remsenburg.
Services: Whole-home renovations, additions, kitchens, bathrooms, basements.
Business history: BBB records the current corporation’s 2013 start; company materials describe a longer history.
License status: County verification pending; company lists Suffolk H-47583.
Why we selected them
A detailed Houzz review describes a gut renovation involving an architect, potential ceiling changes, purchasing deadlines, and decisions when unexpected conditions arose. Another describes returning to the company for a whole-home project after earlier work. These accounts support considering LICC for renovations that require several trades and ongoing decisions.
What makes them different
The company describes a process using 3D designs, defined allowances, and an estimate after planning. Customers independently mention its construction portal and communication about costs. Ask to see how those documents would work for your project.
What to know before contacting them
Other review aggregators show lower scores than Houzz, and their counts vary. We could not establish a dependable Google snapshot. Request recent references from a renovation of similar scope. Confirm design fees, the allowance schedule, and how concealed conditions would change the price before authorizing work.
Shells Only Complete Home Improvements
West Babylon
Best for: Adding a dormer or second story to an existing home.
Review snapshotHouzz 4.7/5, three reviews; additional project accounts appear on Reddit.
Budget informationNo current minimum verified.
Service area: Nassau and Suffolk.
Services: Dormers, extensions, home construction, kitchens, bathrooms.
Business history: BBB records a 1984 start.
License status: County verification pending; profile lists Nassau H1880590000 and Suffolk 1251HI.
Why we selected them
Shells Only has project-specific recommendations in homeowner discussions about dormers. In a 2024 Reddit thread comparing contractors, one homeowner describes hiring the company for a split-level dormer and being satisfied with the work. A separate 2026 discussion includes another positive account of a completed dormer.
What makes them different
The company’s service focus matches the work described in those discussions. Its portfolio includes dormers, and it advertises architectural planning through construction. This makes it a relevant estimate candidate when your main goal is adding upstairs living space.
What to know before contacting them
The Houzz sample is small, and anonymous posts cannot establish a success rate. One Reddit customer said drawings were included in their quote but permits were excluded. Get your own inclusion list covering plans, permit fees, HVAC, siding, flooring, painting, and finish work. Confirm whether the proposal delivers a shell or completed rooms.
Center Island Contracting
Farmingdale
Best for: A substantial addition or renovation with a budget above $100,000.
Review snapshotHouzz 4.9/5, 91 reviews; Trustindex reproduces 4.6/5 from 73 Google reviews.
Budget informationHouzz lists $100,000–$1 million and describes its typical customer as spending over $100,000.
Service area: Nassau and Suffolk; confirm East End availability.
Services: Additions, whole-home remodeling, kitchens, bathrooms, design-build.
Business history: BBB records a 2005 start.
License status: County verification pending; profile lists Nassau H0433930000 and Suffolk 46073-H.
Why we selected them
Center Island’s published project scale helps homeowners assess fit. Customer feedback includes a 1,450-square-foot extension and a renovation that expanded a two-bedroom home to four bedrooms. Those accounts support including it among estimate candidates for larger projects.
What makes them different
Reviews describe design assistance, selections, and construction coordination. Its stated budget range provides a clearer starting point than a general promise to handle every project.
What to know before contacting them
Feedback is mixed across platforms. One 2026 reviewer criticized pricing and change management; the company disputed that the reviewer was a client. BBB also reports one complaint in three years, without published details. Separately, a 2018 state order imposed a $2,500 excavation-notification penalty concerning work at the owner’s residence. Ask about change-order pricing, supervision, and excavation procedures. These records warrant discussion; they do not establish the outcome of your project.
Which two or three companies should you contact?
Start with location and scope. These combinations are editorial suggestions based on the evidence above. Confirm service area, project minimum, and availability before scheduling visits.
| Your project | Start with | What to compare |
|---|---|---|
| Nassau kitchen with custom storage | OZ, DJ’s, NDA | Cabinet construction, layout help, material allowances |
| Suffolk kitchen plus adjoining rooms | NDA, Magic Touch, Kuhn | Structural scope, schedule, responsibility for finishing work |
| Bathroom in central or western Suffolk | Preferred, Islandwide, Magic Touch | Waterproofing, subfloor preparation, fixture allowances, repair terms |
| Whole-home renovation in Brookhaven | LICC, Kuhn, NDA | Design process, supervision, changes after demolition |
| Dormer or second-story addition | Shells Only, Kuhn, Center Island | Plans, permits, structural work, mechanical systems, finish exclusions |
| Nassau renovation with accessibility needs | DJ’s, OZ | Recent relevant references, clearances, thresholds, fixture placement |
For a Hamptons, North Fork, or Shelter Island project, confirm coverage first. This research found more comparable evidence for Nassau and western or central Suffolk than for firms specializing in the East End. Inclusion in this guide does not establish availability in every town.
How can you check whether a remodeling company is trustworthy?
Start by using reviews to decide whom to interview. Then check the business you would actually sign with.
For a more detailed process, read our guide to choosing a remodeling contractor on Long Island. It covers six checks to make before hiring, along with a worksheet to compare contractors.
Here’s a quick overview.
- Verify the legal business name and current license. Nassau County provides a license lookup through Consumer Affairs. Suffolk provides a license and complaint search. Ask your municipality about additional requirements for the work.
- Request insurance documentation. Confirm that it names the contracting business and covers the period when your project will take place.
- Speak with recent customers if possible. Ask about a project similar to yours. Include someone whose work finished long enough ago to discuss repairs or callbacks.
- Get comparable written estimates. Give each company the same scope. Separate allowances, exclusions, permit responsibilities, and owner-supplied materials.
- Agree on changes and payments in writing. Identify who approves additional work, how it is priced, and what completed work triggers each payment.
Nassau’s homeowner checklist addresses license checks, contracts, materials, guarantees, and payments. Suffolk Consumer Affairs recommends three written estimates and checking licensing and open complaints.
What should you ask during the first call?
We’re planning a [project] in [town]. Our working budget is [amount], including [materials, design, and other costs]. Do you take projects like this? What would your estimate include, who would manage the job, and can you share two recent examples?
Choose the companies that answer those questions clearly. Then compare their written proposals against the same scope before deciding who will work on your home.
Planning a Home Remodel on Long Island?
Tell us a little about your project, and we'll get back to you to talk through your options.