Best Hotels on Long Island, NY
Love Local Long Island is your go-to destination for finding the best hotels on Long Island. With charming waterfront views, world-class amenities, and proximity to vineyards, beaches, and historic towns, Long Island luxury hotels offer unforgettable experiences for all types of travelers.
We’ll walk you through the best hotels on Long Island, NY, uncovering where to stay, what to expect, and how to choose the right one for your itinerary. From 5-star hotels to nice hotels with cozy aesthetics and top-tier customer service, you’ll find accommodations that suit your taste, style, and budget.
What to Expect in the Best Hotels on Long Island
The best hotels go beyond basic lodging; they provide premium amenities that elevate your stay. Here’s what you can typically expect from Long Island luxury hotels:
Vineyard Views
Enjoy scenic vistas of the Atlantic Ocean or lush North Fork vineyards directly from your room. These breathtaking views offer peace, inspiration, and a strong connection to the natural beauty of Long Island.
Spa & Wellness Services
Many 5-star hotels feature full-service spas with massage therapy, hot stone treatments, facials, steam rooms, and more. Wellness retreats and yoga programs are also offered at several high-end properties.
Fine Dining
Expect gourmet dining experiences that highlight seasonal, locally sourced ingredients. Many luxury hotels on Long Island, NY feature award-winning chefs, private dining rooms, and curated wine-pairing menus for elevated culinary enjoyment.
Concierge Services
Luxury hotels provide personalized concierge and butler services to assist with everything from activity planning and reservations to in-room celebrations, transportation, and exclusive local experiences.
Heated Pools
Enjoy year-round swimming with temperature-controlled pools, often surrounded by lounge areas, fire pits, or cabanas. These heated pools are ideal for unwinding after a day of exploring or business meetings.
Rooftop Lounges
Sip cocktails while enjoying panoramic views of the coastline or city skyline. Rooftop lounges at the best hotels on Long Island often feature live music, fire pits, and romantic sunset seating.
Fully Equipped Fitness Centers
Stay on top of your fitness routine with 24/7 gym access featuring modern cardio machines, free weights, yoga mats, and personal training options. Select Long Island luxury hotels even offer wellness coaching or fitness classes.
Smart Technology Rooms
Many nice hotels on Long Island feature rooms with smart lighting, climate control, streaming-enabled TVs, and app-based room service, giving guests seamless convenience and full control over their environment.
Featured Destinations
1. The Hamptons – Quintessential Coastal Luxury
Home to some of the most luxury hotels on Long Island, NY, the Hamptons are synonymous with upscale travel. Think beachfront resorts, private pools, and easy access to local wineries and galleries.
2. Montauk – The Surf Town with Five-Star Charm
Montauk offers both relaxed beach vibes and 5-star hotels on Long Island perfect for a romantic getaway or surf-side honeymoon.
3. Garden City – Urban Elegance Close to NYC
If you’re looking for nice hotels on Long Island that offer modern luxury with convenient proximity to New York City, Garden City’s historic and business-class hotels fit the bill.
4. North Fork – Vineyard Views and Rustic Luxury
North Fork’s best hotels offer immersive wine-country experiences paired with boutique luxury. Perfect for foodies and couples seeking a tranquil escape.
Claim your free listing
Get a free business profile that showcases your local business. Promote products and services, include photos, a link to your website, social media, contact information and other important information such as special offers, deals, events, and so on.
Get your business featured
Our goal is to showcase the very best of Long Island and local businesses are the heart and soul of our communities. We would love to spotlight the awesome local business that you are in an upcoming edition of our newsletter or in an in-depth article right here on our blog.
Hotels for Every Travel Style
No matter your reason for travel, there’s a perfect hotel waiting:
For Couples
Choose intimate luxury hotels on Long Island, NY with private balconies, oceanfront dining, and adult-only spa packages.
For Families
Explore nice hotels on Long Island offering kids’ clubs, multi-bedroom suites, and family-friendly excursions like lighthouse tours or aquarium visits.
For Business Travelers
Look for the best hotels on Long Island with conference rooms, high-speed Wi-Fi, and quick transit to JFK or LaGuardia Airport.
For Solo Retreats
Unplug and unwind at wellness-centered resorts offering yoga, meditation, and ocean-view reading lounges.
When to Visit Long Island’s Best Hotels
1. Summer
Peak season for beach lovers and event-goers with sunny weather, luxury pool parties, art festivals, and vibrant coastal nightlife everywhere.
2. Fall
Perfect time for vineyard tours, apple picking, and cozy weekend escapes at nice hotels on Long Island surrounded by colorful autumn foliage.
3. Winter
Enjoy tranquil spa weekends, festive holiday décor, indoor fireplaces, and romantic getaways at quiet luxury hotels offering winter specials and amenities.
4. Spring
Experience blooming gardens, scenic coastal hikes, and fewer crowds while securing lower rates at some of the best hotels on Long Island.
Why Trust Love Local Long Island?
When we recommend the best hotels on Long Island, it’s not based on algorithms, it’s based on real stays, authentic reviews, and insider knowledge of the region.
1. Expertise
Our seasoned travel writers and local reviewers live right here on Long Island, offering genuine insights based on daily experiences and extensive regional familiarity.
2. Experience
We personally visit, evaluate, and stay in the top-rated properties to ensure our recommendations truly reflect the best hotels and services available.
3. Authority
Our guides and content are regularly featured in regional publications and relied on by thousands of monthly users planning their Long Island getaways.
Featured Local Businesses
Discover great local businesses across Nassau and Suffolk counties.
Wading River, NY 11792, USA... 
Babylon, NY, USA... 
Anthony Montani Landscaping, H... 
Long Island Electric Bike Rentals
Experience the beauty of Long Island like never before.
East Islip, NY, USA... 
20 Duneway Ave, Ocean Beach, N... 
51 Joan Ave., Centereach, NY, ... 
East Islip Web Design
Websites for businesses in the Islips, Bay Shore, Oakdale, and Babylon
East Islip, NY, USA... Latest Listings
Clean Steam and Restoration
Suffolk County’s trusted choice for professional carpet cleaning.
West Islip, NY, USA... 
Celebrations In The Kitchen
Authentic baking experiences, parties and events for children and adults
63 East Old Country Road, Hick... 
Camps 'R' Us
Camps ’R’ Us is Long Island’s award-winning private day camp for kids ages 3–14. For over 30 years,
35 Heisser Court, Farmingdale,... Book Your Dream Stay with the Best Hotels in Long Island
Don’t settle for just a place to sleep. With so many 5-star hotels and hidden boutique gems to choose from, you deserve a stay that reflects your style, your needs, and your desire for luxury. At Love Local Long Island, we handpick and highlight the best hotels that deliver comfort, beauty, and service at its finest. Explore your options now, compare luxury stays, and book your perfect Long Island hotel today.
Featured Articles
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, Long Island has its share of high-end spots perfect for couples. The Hamptons and North Fork are where you’ll find luxury resorts and boutique inns with spa services, ocean views, and candlelit dining. Think Montauk sunsets, vineyard tours, and quiet beaches — you’ll have no problem setting the mood.
Plenty. Families love resorts near the big beaches like Jones Beach or Montauk, where you’ve got sand, surf, and boardwalk activities right outside your door. The North Fork also has family-friendly inns near farms and wineries (yes, wineries are kid-friendly here — lots of them have space for kids to run around while parents sip). Look for hotels with pools, easy beach access, and on-site dining to keep things simple.
Definitely. Many luxury hotels in Montauk, East Hampton, and Fire Island offer direct access to their own slice of sand. If private beachfront is a must, book early — summer weekends sell out fast. Locals know: shoulder season (May or September) is the sweet spot for scoring a quieter stay with the beach all to yourself.
Yes, and it pays to check. Summer is peak season, so prices run high. But in spring and fall, many hotels roll out specials — wine tours, spa packages, or extended stay deals. Sign up for hotel newsletters or call directly (yes, people still do that) to ask about unlisted packages.
Location and convenience. If your meetings are closer to the city, look in western Nassau County near the LIRR for easy access. If you’re heading out east, find a spot with strong Wi-Fi, on-site dining, and maybe even a quiet bar to wind down. Business travelers often book hotels near Melville, Hauppauge, or Garden City — all central hubs with plenty of amenities.
Yes — and more than you’d think. Many boutique inns and even upscale resorts allow pets (sometimes with a small fee). Montauk and the Hamptons especially have dog-friendly hotels since so many visitors bring their pups for beach walks. Just double-check pet policies before you book.
Depends on how far east you’re going. Nassau County hotels (closer to Queens) are about 30–45 minutes from Manhattan. Head out to the Hamptons or Montauk and you’re looking at 2–3 hours by car — longer with summer traffic. The LIRR is an option too, with direct routes to places like Montauk, Long Beach, and Greenport.
Yes, the eco-travel trend has reached Long Island. Some boutique hotels and inns on the North Fork and East End focus on sustainability with farm-to-table dining, solar energy, and eco-friendly amenities. You’ll also find vineyard stays and B&Bs that highlight local, organic products — perfect if you want to travel lighter on the planet while still enjoying luxury.