The Story Behind the Long Island Iced Tea

The Long Island Iced Tea is a beloved and refreshing cocktail that has gained popularity around the world. It has a fascinating history, with multiple claims to its origins and a wide range of variations. In this article, we will dive into the true story behind the Long Island Iced Tea, uncovering its origins, classic recipe, evolution, and cultural impact.

Unsubstantiated Origin Stories: The “Long Island” Connection

Two intriguing origin stories add to the mystique of the Long Island Iced Tea. Both tales are associated with the geographical region of Long Island, adding a touch of local lore to the cocktail’s history.

Old Man Bishop and the Prohibition Era

One tale of Long Island Iced Tea’s origins takes us back to the 1920s during the country’s Prohibition era. It is said that the drink is attributed to a figure known as Charlie “Old Man” Bishop, who was believed to be an illegal liquor distiller. According to this story, Bishop created the drink on “Long Island,” a small island in the Holston River located in Kingsport, Tennessee.

During a time when alcohol was illegal and scarce, there was a strong desire for drinks to be stronger. As a result, Old Man Bishop wanted to craft a potent concoction that would look and taste like iced tea, but that would also be full of alcohol and pack a wicked punch.

According to legend, Bishop even passed down the recipe to his son Ransom, who refined it during the 1940s. Despite the popularity of this origin story and there being little evidence to support it, this origin story adds an air of intrigue to the drink’s history and an interesting wrinkle to the Prohibition era.

Robert Butt, a Long Island Story

Another origin story suggests that the Long Island Iced Tea wasn’t invented until the 1970s. However, within this version, the tale ties the cocktail’s creation to our homeland Long Island here in New York. It is said that a bartender named Robert Butt, hailing from Long Island, created the Long Island Iced Tea in the 1970s. There are three versions floating around about how Butt came to actually create the cocktail.

Version 1: The 1972 Cocktail Clash
As a former bartender at the Oak Beach Inn, Butt claims to have invented the drink as his entry in a 1972 cocktail-crafting competition contest where he was tasked to create an original cocktail featuring triple sec.

Version 2: Smoothing Out the Wrinkles
Another version suggests Butt created the drink after being tasked to come up with a new mixed drink that would mask the strong taste of cheap liquors, allowing patrons to enjoy their drinks without wrinkling their noses.

Version 3: End of Season Spirits
In this version, Butt was said to have created the drink as a way to use up extra spirits at the end of the season, and the recipe quickly caught on among locals.

Regardless of which version is true, the exact details of Butt’s story and the drink’s connection to Long Island are subject to speculation. Nevertheless, these elements contribute an additional level of allure to the cocktail’s captivating history.

A Product of the 80s?

Whichever story you believe, it wasn’t until the 1980s that the Long Island Iced Tea really took off across the United States. It became a go-to drink for college students and party-goers, and was featured in movies and TV shows as a symbol of wild and crazy fun.

The Long Island “Iced Tea” Myth

Despite its name, the Long Island Iced Tea does not contain any actual tea. The misconception arises from the cocktail’s appearance, which resembles a glass of iced tea. The name is purely descriptive of its color and taste, showcasing the skill of mixologists in creating a drink that mimics the beloved summer beverage.

However, behind this clever illusion lies the true magic of the Long Island Iced Tea. Let’s dive into the precise recipe required to craft this legendary cocktail.

The Classic Long Island Iced Tea Recipe

The classic Long Island Iced Tea recipe combines several liquors, including vodka, rum, tequila, gin, and triple sec. It also includes a splash of lemon juice, cola, and simple syrup. The combination of these ingredients creates a flavorful and potent cocktail that is synonymous with summer parties and beachside bars. The precise measurements and ratios of the liquors may vary depending on personal preference and regional variations.

DIY: Making a Long Island Iced Tea

To make a Long Island Iced Tea at home, you’ll need the following ingredients:

• 1/2 ounce vodka
• 1/2 ounce tequila
• 1/2 ounce rum
• 1/2 ounce gin
• 1/2 ounce triple sec
• 1 ounce fresh lemon juice
• Splash of cola
• Ice cubes

Now, let’s walk through the step-by-step preparation:

1. Fill a cocktail shaker with ice cubes.
2. Add the vodka, tequila, rum, gin, triple sec, and fresh lemon juice to the shaker.
3. Shake the mixture vigorously for about 15-20 seconds to combine the flavors and chill the ingredients.
4. Strain the mixture into a tall glass filled with fresh ice cubes.
5. Add a splash of cola to the glass, which will give the drink its characteristic tea-like color.
6. Optionally, you can garnish the drink with a lemon wedge or mint sprig for an extra touch of freshness.
7. Stir gently to mix the cola with the other ingredients.
8. Your homemade Long Island Iced Tea is now ready to be enjoyed!

The Evolution of the Long Island Iced Tea

Over the years, the Long Island Iced Tea has evolved, giving rise to numerous variations and creative adaptations. Mixologists and bartenders have embraced the versatility of the Long Island Iced Tea, experimenting with different spirits and flavors to put their unique spin on the classic cocktail. These variations cater to diverse taste preferences and add excitement to the drink’s repertoire. Some popular adaptations include The Tokyo Tea, which incorporates Midori and lemon-lime soda, and The Long Beach Iced Tea, which substitutes cranberry juice for the cola. These creative twists showcase the cocktail’s adaptability and have contributed to its enduring popularity.

The Go-To Cocktail for Early 20s Newbie Drinkers?

The Long Island Iced Tea also gained a reputation among partygoers and newbie alcohol drinkers in their early 20s who are looking to let loose and have a good time. Its deceptive resemblance to a harmless iced tea, combined with its easy-to-down and sweet taste, makes it a popular choice for those who want to get a little wild without the strong taste of actual alcohol.

Not long after its rise to fame in the United States, the Long Island Iced Tea began to make waves around the world. It became a staple in bars and nightclubs, beloved by cocktail enthusiasts and partygoers alike. Its combination of different liquors and its deceptive resemblance to a harmless iced tea made it a popular choice for those looking to enjoy a night out.

Health Implications and Moderation

Given its multiple spirits and high alcohol content, it’s important to consume Long Island Iced Tea responsibly and in moderation. This cocktail packs a punch and can quickly lead to intoxication if consumed in excess. It’s crucial to be mindful of your alcohol intake and prioritize your well-being.

Other Fun Facts About the Long Island Iced Tea

• The Long Island Iced Tea is often referred to as a deceptive drink due to its ability to mask its alcoholic strength.
• The International Bartenders Association recognizes the Long Island Iced Tea as an official cocktail.
• The Long Island Iced Tea has inspired various spin-off cocktails, such as the Electric Lemonade and the Tokyo Tea.

Conclusion: Raising a Toast to the Enigmatic History of the Long Island Iced Tea

Either way, raise your glass and toast to the captivating history of the Long Island Iced Tea! Whether it was born out of a creative bartender’s experiment or a secretive invention during Prohibition, this iconic cocktail has stood the test of time, and it’s whacky history adds to the cocktail’s mystique and intrigue. So next time you find yourself at a beachside bar or a vibrant party, if you are feeling frisky and have a designated driver, consider ordering a Long Island Iced Tea and savor the unique combination of flavors that have made it a timeless classic. As you take each sip, let your thoughts wander to the enigmatic figures such as Old Man Bishop and Robert Butt, and all the innovative bartenders who have contributed to the legacy of this beloved cocktail. Cheers to the legendary drink that continues to bring joy and delight to countless gatherings and celebrations!

The Long Island Iced Tea FAQs

How did the Long Island Iced Tea get its name?

The true story of the history Long Island Iced Tea is said to have gotten its name due to its resemblance to iced tea. The combination of different liquors and the splash of cola creates a drink that visually resembles the classic iced tea we all know and love.

Is the Long Island Iced Tea really from Long Island?

While the drink bears the name “Long Island,” its true origins are still a subject of debate. Although it was popularized in Long Island, New York, its exact birthplace and creator are often disputed. However, it is widely accepted that the drink gained popularity in the Long Island region, hence the association.

Is the Long Island Iced Tea a strong cocktail?

Yes, the Long Island Iced Tea is known for its strong alcohol content due to the combination of multiple spirits. It’s important to drink responsibly.

Can I customize the Long Island Iced Tea to suit my taste preferences?

Absolutely! The Long Island Iced Tea is a versatile cocktail that can be customized to your liking. You can experiment with different ratios of liquors or even add a twist of your favorite flavors to make it uniquely yours.

Does the Long Island Iced Tea contain tea as an ingredient?

Despite its name, the Long Island Iced Tea does not contain any tea. The name is purely descriptive of its appearance and taste.

Can I enjoy a non-alcoholic version of the Long Island Iced Tea?

While the traditional recipe includes alcoholic spirits, you can create a non-alcoholic version by omitting the liquors and replacing them with non-alcoholic substitutes. There are many mocktail recipes available that offer a similar flavor profile without the alcohol.

What occasions are best suited for enjoying a Long Island Iced Tea?

The Long Island Iced Tea is a versatile cocktail that can be enjoyed on various occasions. It’s often associated with summer parties, beach gatherings, and social events where a refreshing and vibrant drink is desired.

Are there any recommended alternatives to cola for the Long Island Iced Tea?

Some variations of the Long Island Iced Tea use lemon-lime soda or ginger ale instead of cola for a different taste experience.

Can I customize the Long Island Iced Tea by adding additional ingredients?

Absolutely! The Long Island Iced Tea offers room for experimentation and personalization. You can try adding